LITTLE NOTES
2001 Little Notes ARTICLES
Letters |
MARCH 2001 LITTLE NOTES
MCCONNELL OVERRULED ON SIGNS. The Fourth Appellate Court District issued a ruling on January 21 declaring parts of a Planned Parenthood injunction against local activists as unconstitutional. Pro-lifers Ronald Brock and Cheryl Sullenger had appealed Superior Court Judge Judith McConnell's preliminary injunction banning picture signs larger than 8 1/2 by 10 inches from within 100 yards of the Planned Parenthood abortion mill in Mission Valley. The court ruled that no such limitations could be put on the size of signs and set aside the distance restrictions.The injunction had prohibited pro-lifers from handing literature to anyone 16 years old or younger. The appellate court rejected that provision.Attorney Bill Gillespie of the United States Justice Foundation, who represented Brock and Sullenger, considered the ruling good news. "We won on the most important issues of law, "he said. Although other provisions of the injunction were upheld, including a 25-foot buffer zone around the clinic's only entrance, Gillespie seemed confident that those more minor issues could be dealt with successfully during the trial. No trial date has been set in the case first filed in March, 1999, against Brock, Sullenger, Sylvia Sullivan, Troy Newman, Ken Scott, and Scott's wife, JoAnn. Sullivan and Mrs. Scott were dismissed earlier from the case and each awarded $11,000 in attorney fees, a decision Planned Parenthood attorney James McElroy is appealing. During the protest, a woman approached pro-lifer Ken Davies and told him "You are a blot on the landscape." Pointing to his poster, Davies responded, "You are so angry because you have consented to this. You are celebrating murder." The woman walked past two female pro-lifers to confront Royce Sullivan, telling him, "You are a disgusting creature." Several motorists including the driver of a San Diego Charter Company bus made obscene gestures at the group; however, one jogger gave a thumbs-up sign as he ran past saying, "Thank God we've finally elected a president who has some pineapples." News Notes reporter Allyson Smith spotted a car license plate that said "BARKACS." Following the vehicle into Tom Ham's parking lot, she confronted Craig Barkacs, USD professor and candidate for Duncan Hunter's congressional seat in November. "Are you Craig Barkacs?" Smith asked. "Yes, I am," answered Barkacs. "Did you run against Duncan Hunter?" "Yes, I did." "Do you teach at USD?" "Yes, I do." "Are you here for the banquet?" pressed Smith. "Yes, I am," confirmed Barkacs. Smith identified herself as a writer for News Notes and asked Barkacs how he could teach at a Catholic university and attend a pro-abortion banquet. Barkacs responded, "Your school [USD] is in favor of academic freedom, and that's why I support freedom of choice." "You can't support this," said Smith. Barkacs insisted, "I do support the right of people to decide for themselves; I really do, and I'd be a hypocrite [to do otherwise]." Police presence was unusually heavy; officers in full riot gear from La Mesa and the San Diego police departments observing the gathering. Later that morning nearly 40 of the pro-life supporters participated in a prayer walk in the neighborhood of abortionist Robert Santella. Santella is serving a four-year term of probation with the Medical Board of California, his second such disciplinary action, for hurting women in his ob-gyn practice. Led by Pastor Adlai Mack of Christians United in the Word of God and Pastor Gary Cass of San Diego Christians United, the group gathered to pray for Santella's repentance and conversion. A smaller group of about 30 gathered in the late afternoon at the First United Methodist Church in Mission Valley during an evening service there to expose the congregation's support of abortion. Preaching and prayers over a bullhorn by pastors Mack and Cass underscored the Biblical position on respect for life and begged the church to come to repentance. On Sunday, January 21, the California Life Coalition sponsored a memorial service at West Hills Christian Fellowship. Pastor Ralph Ovadal, from Wisconsin Christians United exhorted the group of over 100. Testimonies were given by David Garcia and Evelyn Wills of San Diego Christians United, who told of babies saved through their activism. The coalition held a press conference on the Roe v. Wade anniversary in front of Planned Parenthood in Mission Valley to comment on President Bush's decision that morning to ban funding of groups that provide or promote abortion in foreign countries. Sylvia Sullivan and Pastor Gary Cass praised Bush's decision and called for Governor Gray Davis to follow suit. Sullenger contacted attorney Katie Short of Life Legal Defense Foundation, which helps pro-life activists. Short faxed a letter to city attorney Casey Gwynn, mayor Dick Murphy, and San Diego police chief David Bejarano clarifying that San Diego's ordinance does indeed not restrict information on signs since content-based restrictions are unconstitutional. Short was contacted two days later by assistant city attorney Leslie Devaney who concurred that the address signs were legal and assured her that Sullenger's groups would have no problems conducting their usual activities in Santella's neighborhood. During the event, police were courteous and there were no incidents. "Everything went very smoothly, thanks to Katie and Life Legal Defense," noted Sullenger. "She had a response on the city attorney's desk within three hours of the initial call from the police." A receptionist in the office of abortionist Bruce Tarzy indicated to a recent caller that he also would not prescribe RU486. "He thinks its a hassle for women," she said. But before the first pamphlet could be handed out an adult dressed in a Granite Hills lacrosse team T-shirt approached pro-lifer Steve Klein. "He was threatening me, but I just walked away," Klein said. The man left and returned a few minutes later with a lacrosse stick and seemed to be on friendly terms with the high school staff. He later tried to pick a fight with pro-lifer Mike Horutz but the police intervened and sent the man on his way. Pro-lifers had video cameras rolling as the bell sounded to dismiss students for the day. As one student approached them, he removed his jacket to display his T-shirt, "Get God Out of El Cajon." Another student knocked fliers out of a pro-lifer's hands and kicked over a stack of pamphlets that had been placed on the sidewalk. "Although there were no physical attacks, I think this time was actually worse than the first," noted Ronald Brock, who arrived in a motor home sporting a large sign bearing the Ten Commandments. Staffers told students to keep moving and discouraged them from accepting the pamphlets or talking with the pro-lifers. One girl stopped to look at the signs and was approached by a male staffer who put his arm around her and walked her away from the signs. An woman, identified as Linda, attempted to place a painting over photos held by the pro-lifers. Two other women arrived with a sheet and held it over one of the pro-life signs, all the while bumping and jostling with the protesters. Complaints to the El Cajon Police officers on duty, including Lieutenant Jim Cunningham, fell on deaf ears. |